A real Tiffany necklace is a valuable investment one may want to buy. However, with fakes in the market, buying isn’t as straightforward. Learning a few reliable checks will save you time and money. This guide gives simple, practical steps you can use whether you’re buying in person or online.

The tips covered here are also used by experts when conducting a Tiffany authenticity check. 

Here is our complete checklist to spot counterfeit designer bags if you're seeking for a more helpful guide for identifying replica luxury products in general.

The steps are easy, as they do not require any additional equipment. It can all be done by simply knowing what to look for. If you doubt the seller, small tests can reveal whether the piece is likely real.

At Value Creation UAE, we frequently inspect Tiffany pieces that clients bring in for resale, and these are the same checks our team uses during evaluations: professional Tiffany authenticity checks to put your mind at ease. 

But without focusing on authenticity services, let’s consider the ways you can know whether you’ve got a real Tiffany necklace on your hands or not. 

We also explained this in a short TikTok video for easier understanding. Watch our quick TikTok explanation here.

The First Sign: Engraving and Hallmarks

Tiffany engravings are consistently neat and even, so a Tiffany engraving check is a necessity for weeding out the fakes. Look at any stamped name or hallmarks closely. On genuine pieces, the letters are clean, the spacing is balanced, and the depth is uniform.

Fake engravings often show variable depth or slightly different letter shapes. For example, an inconsistent “ff” or uneven spacing in “Tiffany & Co.” is a red flag. Use a magnifier or your phone camera to zoom in and compare.

Also find the metal mark—most Tiffany silver is stamped “925” or “Sterling.” If the stamp is missing, poorly done, or looks etched by hand, be cautious. A missing or sloppy hallmark is a common sign of a replica.

Check out our guide on how to determine if a Fendi bag is real. Engraving is an important clue. This will help you become more aware of design mistakes.

The Second Sign: Material and Finish

Real Tiffany necklaces use premium materials. It has sterling silver that oxidizes and gives it a little dark look with time. However, unlike other materials, this can be polished to return it to its original state. A fake’s materials will not return to the original finish when polished.

Another thing to look out for is the weight. Authentic Tiffany jewelry pieces are heavy, as they give off a premium feel due to their construction. Fakes, however, might feel lightweight. Edges are smooth, and joints should be neat.

Even if our years of authenticating Tiffany pieces, weight and finish have been two of the first things we notice when assessing sterling-silver jewelry. 

Here's a breakdown of why luxury materials differ between designer brands, so you can compare their quality.

Following are some steps you can do by yourself to check for authentic Tiffany jewelry products:

• Polish test: Rub gently with a soft cloth. Sterling will brighten; cheap plating often flakes or shows base metal.

• Magnet test: Sterling silver is not magnetic. If a strong magnet sticks, the piece likely contains ferrous metals. In fact, many sellers we’ve worked with are surprised at how quickly a simple magnet or polish test exposes lower-grade replicas!

• Look for discoloration: Check where the chain meets the clasp and at the links—heavy discoloration often points to poor plating or low-grade metal.

The Third Sign: Craftsmanship and Design Details

Tiffany is known for fine finishing. Check the clasp, jump rings, and chain links. Real pieces have symmetrical links, secure solder joints, and clasps that close smoothly. Rough seams or visible glue mean low-quality work.

The design should match known Tiffany styles and proportions. Tiny differences in shape, uneven curves, or odd proportions are common in fakes. When possible, compare the piece to official product photos from Tiffany’s site or trusted retailers.

Minor details matter especially. Look at the fonts, shapes of pendants, and the symmetry of patterns. 

The Fourth Sign: Packaging, Papers, and Provenance

The original packaging of a real Tiffany necklace is of high quality. It has its famous blue box, a quality pouch included, and organized tissue wrapping. Replicating this is not an easy task, and this is where many fakes fall apart.

Tiffany authenticity check paperwork and receipts helps, but they can also be forged. Check receipts for consistent formatting and credible seller information. There should be a clear history of ownership and evidence that the product has been bought from a reliable platform.

When checking packaging and papers, look specifically for these items:

• Box and pouch: Strong, well-finished materials; color should be the recognizable Tiffany blue.

• Authenticity card/receipt: Clean print, clear dates, and seller details that you can verify.

• Any serial numbers: If present, note them and ask the seller to verify with official sources when possible.

Where and Who You Buy a Real Tiffany Necklace from?

The best way to avoid any scam is to always go for a trusted seller. The most reliable options are the Tiffany stores directly; however, there are authorized dealers as well that sell original products, as well as resell them, such as Value Creation UAE. 

If you want to buy used goods, always do your research and ensure that the platforms are reliable and that they require authentication for both sellers and buyers. Never go for too-good-to-be-true deals, as it is highly likely that they are scams.

You can always check out our verified collection of designer jewelry and accessories if you want to sell pre-owned luxury that is genuine.

Make sure to analyze the photos, as they can have minor details that can give away a fake. Make sure to mention the return policy. If the sellers are hesitant, it is better to not deal with them and instead choose somewhere else to buy from.

If you are selling, always keep records of your purchase to ensure authenticity. You can also get expert verification from platforms like Value Creation UAE.

All in all, always prioritize sellers who provide transparent photos, verifiable documents, and a clear return policy, because we’re the ones you can trust. 

Final Checks and When to Walk Away From A Fake Tiffany Necklace

Do a final overall check: does the piece look and feel consistent with the brand? Are the engravings, weight, finish, packaging, and seller story all reasonable? If more than one area seems off, it’s safer to walk away.

These steps can help you avoid potential scams and save your money. If you’re still unsure, get an expert’s opinion. Compare your piece using reputable authentication resources or consult professionals who specialize in evaluating designer jewelry.

In easy words? If you’re planning to buy or sell a Tiffany necklace, getting it authenticated first is always worth it, and we, at Value Creation, are here to help you make that safe, confident decision. 

You could also buy directly from our pre-authenticated catalogues to cut down on time! To help you buy with confidence, we also offer verification support for all designer items, including Tiffany.